Advertisement
Hot off the press
The ONW Salon: Should Herb Gray be given a state funeral?

The Salon is ONW's weekly gathering place where three of Canada's brightest and most respected political strategists - John Capobianco , Marit Stiles and Richard Mahoney - come together to analyze national issues affecting Ontario.




Should former Liberal cabinet minister Herb Gray be given a state funeral, given that Jim Flaherty had one?


Richard Mahoney:

Just as many in the government and political circles were beginning to recover from the very sad passing of Jim Flaherty, news of the death of another titan of Canadian politics, the Rt. Hon Herb Gray, arrives.  Herb Gray was an icon in Canadian politics.  An MP for almost 40 years, Herb personified several important characteristics in politics. 

First, like his predecessor in Windsor, Paul Martin Sr., he was renowned for his laser like focus on the people he represented.  He was a powerhouse in Windsor and no issue was too big or small for him.  The smallest immigration case received his attention, as did the famous and successful bail out of Chrysler Corporation in the early eighties, saving thousands of jobs, and Windsor’s economy.

Secondly, Herb was a man of integrity who believed in public service and he left politics with his reputation intact.  No easy feat.

Third, Herb Gray became a legend is Canadian politics by virtue of his longevity and his tenacity.  He kept the Liberal Party alive in Opposition and became known as “The Gray Fog” when defending the sometimes indefensible in Parliament.  For some reason, you couldn’t lay a glove on Herb.  Ask the Conservatives and the NDP!

Given the recent examples of both Jack Layton and Jim Flaherty, the question arises: should the Prime Minister order a state funeral for Herb

Gray?


John Capobianco:

I attended the State Funeral for Jim Flaherty and it was a blessing to have been there to feel the outpouring of affection and respect for Jim from people on all sides of the political spectrum.  To hear from the Prime Minister, Christine and the kids was heart breaking, but there was a sense of closure.  That, I guess, is what state funerals are for – so that the public can share its grief and to have some closure with someone who has given so much with the country.

Although I never met Herb Gray, I do share Richard’s perspective of the man… as a political observer, I found Herb to be larger than life when he was in the House.

As for a state funeral, that is the question, Richard.  Where do we stop or more importantly, where do we draw the line? According to Heritage Canada’s website, the definition of a state funeral is “a public event that may be held to honour and commemorate present and former governors general, present and former prime ministers and sitting members of the Ministry.”  Both Jack Layton and Jim Flaherty technically didn’t fit that description, but I dare anyone to say they didn’t deserve one.


Marit Stiles:

I’m going to dive right in here on the question of the state funerals.  I think there’s little doubt of the respect and - for many - affection felt for these two gentlemen.

Ultimately of course the question of who should be given the honour of a state funeral falls to the Prime Minister.  He would offer the option to the family, and they could accept or not. Not every family will want the public attention, though in my research I think I only found a couple of cases where the family didn’t want to proceed.

I’m not sure what the PM will do now.  But he must – like many of us – be grappling with the difficulty of the situation. By veering away from the ‘norms’ (Layton, Flaherty) and the very restricted definition of who gets a state funeral and who does not, he has landed us all in the very uncomfortable position of defining who is ‘deserving’ and who is not.

There’s some precedent for former cabinet ministers to receive state funerals, even if they are no longer in cabinet, but I believe to date they have all still been sitting MPs.  The one exception seems to have been was Thomas D’Arcy McGee.  And those were quite unusual circumstances.

What was the rationale for Jack Layton receiving the honour?  He had moved a nation. He was a sitting MP and Leader of the Official Opposition.  I don’t believe there was any precedent, however.

Traditions can be changed.  The PM can surely propose some new guidelines for who gets a state funeral and who doesn’t.  I think that’s the road we are headed down.  I certainly wouldn’t want to be the one making this call.


Richard Mahoney:

I agree with Marit and John.  (Wow, how often does that happen?)

Who would want to say that state funerals for Jack Layton and Jim Flaherty weren’t deserved?  First of all, they both passed away tragically, and too soon.  Secondly, while neither was a sitting minister at the time as the policy dictates, Jack Layton had just won an historic victory as Leader of the Opposition, a first for the NDP, and Jim Flaherty had just resigned from cabinet before his heart attack.

But as Marit points out, who would want to make the call in each individual case?  That’s a mile of bad road, when people are understandably going to be touched by the sad circumstances of the death of someone in public life.  

  1. Just the passing of an extraordinary, remarkable Canadian who served his country.

 

John Capobianco:

Since there has been a slight deviation from the strictest meaning of a state funeral as defined by Heritage Canada, I do agree with Marit that the decision(s) moving forward becomes more challenging. As was the case for Jack and Jim, the PM evaluated their situation separately, the profound effect they both had on the country and on Canadians, as well as gauging the public mood.  

Unless the PM does propose new guidelines, the decision will always be made based on whether the deceased person who has served the public fits the definition as laid out by Heritage Canada.  Or, as was the case for Jack Layton and Jim Flaherty, the outright, palpable and extraordinary political courage they displayed at the moment or close to the moment of their passing. 

As Richard correctly states, the passing of Herb Gray has taken place after many years away from the public so my guess would be that the PM does not order a state funeral, but that in no way will take away the work and the public adulation that Herb Gray so richly deserve…. state funeral or not.


Marit Stiles:

I absolutely agree with both of you (yes, I’m a little shocked too).  We all share a deep respect for those who enter public life and who serve as parliamentarians.

For some - and perhaps, ultimately, for Stephen Harper and his cost-cutting ways - the issue will be straightforward and one of cost.  I’ve seen various figures bandied about regarding the cost of a state funeral, and I suppose there are many factors that affect the bottom line.  Holding multiple state funerals every year is going to get costly, however appropriate.

Ultimately, though, it goes again to what factors determine whether that person gets the full-on state funeral treatment.  I would hope that all who devote their lives to public life and political good would be feted at the end.  But a state funeral is not necessarily the only route. And it’s unfortunate to see the issue become so politicized.

A side note, in reviewing the long list of Governors General, Prime Ministers, cabinet ministers etc. that have received such an honour, it was striking to find just one woman among them: Jeanne Sauvé.  Yet another insight into how far we have come as women and how far we have yet to go. Especially in the political sphere.

 

Posted date: April 23, 2014
Category: ontarionewswatch.com NEWSROOM

Latest ontarionewswatch.com NEWS
The rules are somewhat muddied, now that Stephen Harper decided to give the late Jim Flaherty a state funeral. Capobianco, Stiles and Mahoney on this delicate matter.
April 23, 2014
Andrea Horwath and her inner circle have decided to pull the plug on the minority Liberals, forcing a spring election, senior sources have told ONW's Susanna Kelley.
April 21, 2014
Police are breaking the law by routinely reporting suicide attempts to the FBI, U.S. border agents and 300 other agencies, Ontario's Privacy Commissioner Ann Cavoukian tells Susanna Kelley.
April 17, 2014
As goes Ontario, so goes the federal election-usually. But critics say Stephen Harper, who brought us fixed election dates, wants to put the fix in the 2015 campaign with the "Fair Elections Act."
April 16, 2014
The news broke after the PC leader refused to retract charges Wynne "oversaw and possibly ordered the criminal destruction of documents" and MPP Lisa MacLeod compared her to Richard Nixon:
April 16, 2014
Some pundits say Andrea Horwath has no choice but to force a spring election. But as Susanna Kelley writes, from a strategic point of view that's not necessarily true.
April 14, 2014
Premier Wynne is pressing ahead with a libel suit against PC leader Tim Hudak, something he calls attempted "libel chill." Ezrin, Bangs and Ferreira on a divided and rancorous Legislature.
April 10, 2014
With the Quebec election delivering such a crushing rejection of its raison d'etre - a referendum on sovereignty - can the PQ survive? John Capobianco, Marit Stiles and Richard Mahoney discuss.
April 09, 2014
Do a criminal investigation in the Premier's Office and a leaked budget PR plan make a spring election is more or less likely? Ezrin, Bangs and Ferreira weigh in.
April 03, 2014
Conservative leader Tim Hudak says a leaked budget document shows the Liberals are rolling out $5.7 million in spending announcements before tabling the Ontario budget May 1st.
April 02, 2014
Does the firing of Dimitri Soudas show Stephen Harper will tolerate no favouritism in CPC nominations, or is this just another of his appointments gone bad? Capobianco, Stiles and Mahoney debate.
April 02, 2014
The Liberals head for a majority while PQ leader Pauline Marois backs down on sovereignty. Hershell Ezrin, Jeff Bangs and Paul Ferreira on how it affects Ontario.
March 27, 2014
ontarionewswatch.com NEWSROOM
The rules are somewhat muddied, now that Stephen Harper decided to give the late Jim Flaherty a state funeral. Capobianco, Stiles and Mahoney on this delicate matter.
April 23, 2014
Andrea Horwath and her inner circle have decided to pull the plug on the minority Liberals, forcing a spring election, senior sources have told ONW's Susanna Kelley.
April 21, 2014
Police are breaking the law by routinely reporting suicide attempts to the FBI, U.S. border agents and 300 other agencies, Ontario's Privacy Commissioner Ann Cavoukian tells Susanna Kelley.
April 17, 2014
As goes Ontario, so goes the federal election-usually. But critics say Stephen Harper, who brought us fixed election dates, wants to put the fix in the 2015 campaign with the "Fair Elections Act."
April 16, 2014
The news broke after the PC leader refused to retract charges Wynne "oversaw and possibly ordered the criminal destruction of documents" and MPP Lisa MacLeod compared her to Richard Nixon:
April 16, 2014
Some pundits say Andrea Horwath has no choice but to force a spring election. But as Susanna Kelley writes, from a strategic point of view that's not necessarily true.
April 14, 2014
Premier Wynne is pressing ahead with a libel suit against PC leader Tim Hudak, something he calls attempted "libel chill." Ezrin, Bangs and Ferreira on a divided and rancorous Legislature.
April 10, 2014
With the Quebec election delivering such a crushing rejection of its raison d'etre - a referendum on sovereignty - can the PQ survive? John Capobianco, Marit Stiles and Richard Mahoney discuss.
April 09, 2014
Do a criminal investigation in the Premier's Office and a leaked budget PR plan make a spring election is more or less likely? Ezrin, Bangs and Ferreira weigh in.
April 03, 2014
Conservative leader Tim Hudak says a leaked budget document shows the Liberals are rolling out $5.7 million in spending announcements before tabling the Ontario budget May 1st.
April 02, 2014
Does the firing of Dimitri Soudas show Stephen Harper will tolerate no favouritism in CPC nominations, or is this just another of his appointments gone bad? Capobianco, Stiles and Mahoney debate.
April 02, 2014
The Liberals head for a majority while PQ leader Pauline Marois backs down on sovereignty. Hershell Ezrin, Jeff Bangs and Paul Ferreira on how it affects Ontario.
March 27, 2014
onwDOCS
Sandra Pupatello thought she had Eric Hoskins support-until he crossed the convention floor to Kathleen Wynne. Did he change his mind mid-walk? Watch Susanna Kelley's documentary on the convention.
January 29, 2013
There's what you saw of the Liberal convention on TV, and there's what you didn't see. In this ONW documentary, a top Liberal strategist guides us through what was going on behind the scenes.
January 29, 2013
Three of seven Ontario Liberal leadership candidates are claiming the title of "jobs candidate," and all say they can solve an unemployment rate higher than the U.S.' ONW's Susanna Kelley reports on t
December 03, 2012
Are our political leaders safeguarding our democracy, or trying to shut it down? How best to protect it? In Susanna Kelley's new mini-doc, two top political experts don't pull any punches.
September 20, 2012
On July 1, Canada's beloved medicare turns 50. But its journey has been a bitter one, especially in Ontario. Watch Susanna Kelley's short documentary.
May 14, 2012
It will be the king-maker - or queenmaker - in the Ontario election. ONW's Susanna Kelley has prepared this mini-doc on races to watch in the riding rich "905" area near Toronto.
September 01, 2011
When you've got 22 ridings, it's hard not to think of yourself as the centre of the (election) universe. ONW's Susanna Kelley prepared this mini-doc on the races to watch in Toronto.
August 25, 2011
Small Towns, Big Fights: It's the classic story of small town Ontario-PC candidates from establishment families vie with Liberals for power. Here's Susanna Kelley's mini-documentary.
August 18, 2011
ONW travels to a land where the fiercest riding fights are about protecting public services, not cutting them. Susanna Kelley prepared this mini-doc.
August 11, 2011
The J Word: Jobs are the big issue in southwestern Ontario campaign fights. Susanna Kelley checks in on the hot ridings, concluding this week's ONW pre-campaign tour.
August 04, 2011
The Liberals are increasing the number of international university students by 50% over five years. Susanna Kelley looks at whether Ontario students could get squeezed out.
July 07, 2011
There's much more going on than just dropping that platform. Susanna Kelley reports.
June 28, 2011
ontarionewswatch.com Political Panel
Will return when the Legislature re-opens next week.
September 02, 2013
While the OPP investigates deleted emails from top McGuinty aides in the gas plant scandal, the Insiders step back to assess each leader's performance this sitting.
June 11, 2013
PC leader Tim Hudak wants to know if a list of fee increases on or off the table for Liberal Premier Kathleen Wynne. The ONW Insiders with host Susanna Kelley.
June 06, 2013
Will Ontario agree to HST and gas tax hikes to raise $34 billion over 20 years to fight GTHA gridlock? Insiders Hershell Ezrin, Howard Hampton and John Parker on Metrolinx's recommendations.
May 30, 2013
Hershell Ezrin, Jeff Bangs and Howard Hampton on whether NDP budget wins are an example of might over right, or democratic, compromise minority government politics at its finest?
May 23, 2013
Will reports of a video allegedly showing Toronto's mayor smoking crack do in Ford Nation? ONW Insiders Hershell Ezrin, Jeff Bangs and Howard Hampton with host Susanna Kelley.
May 23, 2013
Former Premier Dalton McGuinty says he made the decision to shutter the Mississauga gas plant. But how likely is it he made the eleventh-hour election choice alone?
May 09, 2013
Former Premier Dalton McGuinty cancelled the Mississauga gas plant in mid-campaign without knowing the cost. How often are important policy decisions made on the fly?
May 09, 2013
More money for home care, jobs for youth, lower car insurance rates ... John Snobelen, Howard Hampton and Bob Richardson on whether the Liberals can successfully woo the NDP and avoid an election.
May 03, 2013
The Liberals' May 2nd budget may win NDP support, but is it what Ontario needs? Former PC Premier Ernie Eves, Liberal Bob Richardson and former NDP leader Howard Hampton debate.
April 25, 2013
Justin Trudeau made his debut as Liberal leader in Ottawa this week. He stuck to his theme of championing the middle class. Ezrin, Hampton and Bangs on the strategy behind that.
April 18, 2013
When Justin Trudeau fights the next election, the battlegrounds are clear: seats in Ontario's "905" belt and Quebec. Ezrin, Hampton and Bangs on what he needs to do to win.
April 18, 2013
Taking It To The Street
Would Ontario have lost millions of jobs, and would Canadians have to worry about its government secretly spying on them without warrants, if we'd had a truly democratic system?
October 07, 2013
After two years of the gas plant scandal obsession, Susanna Kelley says the voters' real concern - high unemployment - may finally get the attention it deserves
October 02, 2013
Blame Ontario's conflict-ridden, antiquated political donation rules. It's time the system had a major overhaul, writes ONW's Susanna Kelley.
September 24, 2013
Premier Wynne's new transit panel shows a key difference between the two politicians, Howath tells Susanna Kelley. Actions, not endless talk, will differentiate them next election.
September 19, 2013
Firing those who aspire to your job on the eve of a convention where your leadership is shaky, to say the least, smacks of desperation, not strength, says ONW's Susanna Kelley.
September 16, 2013
Firing the Thornhill MPP for taking a housing allowance of nearly $21,000 for a Niagara On The Lake retirement home won't solve Tim Hudak's credibility gap.
September 09, 2013
And Now, A Dramatic Pause: With Kathleen Wynne and Andrea Horwath's pragmatism, the PC's in disarray, and Stephen Harper in pre-election mode, moderate politics is on the horizon for Ontario.
September 03, 2013
Stephen Harper and Rob Ford share the same damage control strategy, it seems: when in trouble, run away. This is leadership? More from ONW's Susanna Kelley.
May 21, 2013
Will all the political maneuvering leading up to Thursday's Ontario budget avert an election? ONW's Susanna Kelley says we may not know for weeks yet.
April 29, 2013
There's much more to the younger Trudeau's campaign than longing for the more optimistic days of Pierre Elliott Trudeau, says ONW's Susanna Kelley.
April 08, 2013
Kathleen Wynne's vision includes ideas from the PCs, NDP, former leadership rivals and others. Will her consensus politics keep her government afloat?
February 20, 2013
With the first solid evidence in that two women are the frontrunners in the Liberal leadership race, all politicos should note the achievement.
January 14, 2013
THE SALON
What are the feds doing to help more than 500,000 jobless Ontarians? Senator Bob Runciman, Richard Mahoney and Joe Cressy gather in The Salon as ONW’s Jobs Week continues.
January 22, 2014
Accusations are flying that the Prime Minister improperly issued orders to CPC Senators while their colleagues carried out a personal vendetta. Anderson, Mahoney and Stanford sort it out.
October 24, 2013
At a cool $1.1 billion cost, could the gas plant scandal be any worse for the Ontario Liberals? And who will win "The Battle For Ontario" in the next federal election?
October 09, 2013
The feds say they'll kick in $660 million for the Scarborough subway - but is it enough? And, is the NDP ready to rumble in the next Ontario and federal elections?
September 25, 2013
Two economic visions for Canada - the NDP's Linda McCuaig vs. Liberal Christina Freeland's - clash in the Toronto Centre by-election. Also up: Quebec's Charter of Values.
September 18, 2013
As the Legislature opens, will an Ontario financial watchdog fare better than Ottawa's? And Peter Shurman's firing: after Duffy and Wallin, did Tim Hudak have any choice?
September 10, 2013
Trudeau and Legalized Marijuana: An idea whose time has come, or good political strategy? And Syria's alleged chemical weapons: What should Canada do? The Salon is back.
September 05, 2013
The Senate scandal: Can new proposals to audit all Senators' expenses restore faith in the institution? And the union spending bill: dead, or just about to be resurrected?
June 05, 2013
There are no winners in the Rob Ford alleged cocaine video controversy. And, what the robocall court decision says about our voting system, the CPC and Elections Canada.
May 29, 2013
What must PM Harper do after explosive news his former top aide has resigned for writing a personal cheque for $90,000 to Senator Mike Duffy? ONW's national experts discuss.
May 22, 2013
The Liberals say Justin Trudeau is the secret to their by-election win in Labrador. And, is Stephen Harper really thinking about retiring?
May 15, 2013
Can Justin Trudeau's fundraising juggernaut finally allow the Liberals to battle the Harperites' attack ads effectively? And the oil sands: under fire from all sides.
May 08, 2013
onw COLUMNISTS
Political observers were puzzled when Premier Wynne played the election threat card recently, then almost immediately backtracked. Hershell Ezrin has some thoughts on her strategy.
September 17, 2013
Stephen Harper's last two prorogations were the work of a tyrant. This latest one, says parliamentary expert Peter Russell, is the work of a stumble bum prime minister just lurching along.
September 04, 2013
Toronto council's decision against a casino puts the city in perfect sync with the Wynne government - exactly as democracy is supposed to work, says the parliamentary expert
May 28, 2013
Charges in a new book that the late Supreme Court Justice Bora Laskin undermined the repatriation of Canada's constitution in 1982 are just plain wrong.
May 23, 2013
While Premier Wynne has reached out to the opposition leaders with the new budget, Andrea Horwath is playing a game of political chicken we all might live to regret.
May 07, 2013
We can't expect tomorrow's leaders to be effective citizens without teaching them how government works today. But the current mandatory high school civics course being used is inadequate.
April 22, 2013
Whereas his father Pierre faced a constitutional crisis with Quebec threatening to leave Canada, his son faces one of a different sort: a malfunctioning parliamentary democracy.
April 16, 2013
The CPC can't possibly govern intelligently by gagging scientists and stopping them from doing proper scientific research. And that means we'll all pay.
April 10, 2013
Phillippe Couillard's idea to make Quebec a constitutional signatory by 2017 is big mistake. Constitutional expert Russell warns not to go down that road again.
March 25, 2013
The Harper government is refusing a visa to one of the world's leading experts on the rights of indigenous peoples, UN "rapporteur" Dr. James Anaya. Is it afraid of what he may report?
March 19, 2013
Although not a Liberal, the parliamentary expert is endorsing Vancouver MP Joyce Murray for Liberal leader. He particularly likes her ideas to reform our sagging democracy.
March 04, 2013
There are signs that Mr. Harper may be turning to the political centre-a bit. It's easy to see why: his party is lagging in the polls, and he'd like to keep his majority next election.
February 19, 2013
THOUGHT PROVOKERS
The hue and cry over Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird and six vacationing friends staying for free for eight days at Canada's High Commissioner's residence is a tempest in a teapot.
June 27, 2013
The Senate expenses issue is taking up far too much time, says the former PC cabinet minister. Fix it and move on, because there's important work to be done - like getting the economy on track.
June 06, 2013
Between Ottawa's senate spending scandal and the alleged Rob Ford crack cocaine video, it's easy to get cynical about government. But the Liberal advisor has few examples to refute that.
June 05, 2013
The Liberals have survived a Premier's resignation, a leadership campaign and two minority budgets. But raising $32 billion to fight gridlock just may be their undoing, says the former NDP MPP.
May 30, 2013
The Liberal government is set to "trash" legislation it previously passed to protect endangered species, says the Green Party leader. A five year exemption for forestry companies is just one change.
May 28, 2013
The deaths of over 1,000 garment workers in a Bangladesh factory collapse has Canadian manufacturers abroad pressing for labour law reform. Canadian-owned mines abroad should pay close attention.
May 27, 2013
Watching the slow, agonizing implosion of Canada's Senate inspires Professor Wesley-Esquimaux to articulate ideas to make Canada work better.
May 23, 2013
The very real problems with modern polling have been highlighted once again in the BC election. The real losers are the media, which must get back to reporting on actual elections, not just the polls.
May 22, 2013
Funding a major public transit expansion in the GTA is a matter of hot debate right now. Doing that in a fair way is possible, says Mackenzie, and he has some new ideas on how to accomplish that.
May 22, 2013
Ontario's budget is a brilliant piece of political strategy by the Liberals. It's really all about taking away three more seats from the NDP in the next election.
May 15, 2013
The massive cost of moving gas plants in Mississauga and Oakville was eminently predictable and avoidable. The public-private partnership took away government power but stuck it with the bill.
May 14, 2013
New census data just released says 20 per cent of Canadians were born outside this country, providing a healthy multicultural mix. But new Canadians have unique problems that need addressing.
May 13, 2013