Taking It To The Street

Spending Cuts a Challenge for McGuinty in the Era of "Occupy" Movement

By Susanna Kelley

Susanna Kelley

Tin soldiers and Nixon coming

We're finally on our own

This summer I hear the drumming

Four dead in Ohio.

   - Neil Young, "Ohio", May 21,1970

Kent u

Mary Ann Vecchio kneels in shock and 
horror beside the body of Jeffrey Miller, 
who was shot by the Ohio National Guard at Kent State University,
May 4 1970. This iconic photo by John Filo won a Pultizer Prize.

We must give the poor their due, or they will take it from us.

   - the late Allan Grossman, Ontario PC cabinet minister and  MPP, 1955-1975


Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty's new government will face a major financial challenge over the next years - and with it, perhaps a social challenge more serious than any seen for the last 40 years.

Finance Minister Dwight Duncan revealed last week Ontario's economy shrunk by 0.3 per cent in the second quarter of 2011.

And while he's confident of a GDP bounce in the third quarter, there are still many storm clouds on the economic horizon.

The European Union deal to provide a bailout for Greece totaling €130b was greeted with great relief at first.

But that and the fact private investors have agreed to take a 50% haircut in the face value of their Greek bonds seem to have appeased the markets for only a couple of days.

Here in Ontario, the truth is, while Mr. Duncan can make soothing sounds and quote economists to back up his assertion that the third quarter will be better, both governments and private sector economists hardly have stellar records when it comes to predictions. 

Finance ministers frequently low-ball their budgetary growth predictions - on purpose.  That way it's "good news" when a better figure is attained.

As for even the top economists, how often do we hear they are "revising their predictions" in light of new economic events?  (You'd be forgiven for asking "what kind of predictions are those, then?"  Those would be incorrect predictions.  We should all be so lucky to have high paying jobs that allow us to "revise our predictions" so often.)

In truth, no one really knows what's on the economic horizon for Ontario. But with the US stuck in economic quicksand, we certainly can't depend on our biggest trading partner to keep us afloat.

Which brings us to Mr. McGuinty's dilemna. 

He has promised to bring the budget to a balanced position by 2017-2018.

Everyone knows that means cuts are coming. And cuts usually mean layoffs.

As the various factions of society cast about for ways to fix the financial shortfall, you can hear the polarized yelling matches loud and clear.

Some conservatives have ramped up their fight against public sector unions, and indeed, against all unions.  They are particularly galled that public sector employees enjoy guarantees of comfortable pensions and benefits paid for by private sector workers who don't have anything near that. 

The left says the solution is not to cut public sector compensation but to unionize private sector workers so they have equally good benefits.  They point out the mortgage fraud shows human nature has not changed, and so the time for union relevance is far from over.

The "Occupy" movement, which began with New York's "Occupy Wall Street" and has spread to Canada and other countries, accuses the top 1% in the U.S. of raking in large incomes while the other 99% have been flat lined in the last 30 years.

protest sign 

Protester with sign at one of the "Occupy" demonstrations.

Let's look at the union argument first.

First of all, unions, along with education and some social programs, are one of the great income levelers of our time.  It is no coincidence that income levels have stagnated over the last three decades as union membership decreased.   

Free trade, initiated in 1980's by Conservative Prime Minister Brian Mulroney, decimated the already shaky steel industry, and tore up the auto pact whereby auto jobs were guaranteed here. Then, just like a mother bird pushing her babies out of the nest, Mulroney and his Liberal successors Jean Chretien and Paul Martin, pushed the nation into the a globalized free market, free trade world that pitted Canadian workers against countries paying much lower wages.

As the number of jobs - especially in manufacturing - decreased, so did, naturally, the rate of private sector union membership.

Meanwhile, only the top 20% of income earners have increased their take of the nation's wealth since 1976, according to the Conference Board of Canada. By 2009 (latest figures available) they claimed 39.2% of the nation's income.  This was not due to investments they held but rather high salaries, the Conference Board says.

Meantime, the poor and middle income groups stagnated. Median income went from $45,800 in 1976 to $48,300 in 2009.

5.5% in 33 years.

The gap between the richest 20% and the poorest grew from $92,300 in 1976 to $117,000 in 2009.

Paul Krugman, the 2008 winner of the Nobel Prize for Economics, says this was due to lower rates of unionization, flat-lined minimum wage rates and deregulation, and policies favouring the wealthy.

Meanwhile in the U.S. the situation was even worse. Between 1980 and 2007, the income of the richest 1 per cent rose 197 per cent.

The solution is obvious, say the OWS protesters:  tax that 1% more and then redistribute the wealth more equitably.

However, as Conservatives point out, figures from the U.S. Tax Foundation show that in 2009, the top 0.1 % - about 140,000 Americans with incomes of about $4 million  - paid over 17% of all US taxes. 

The top 1%, with incomes above $344,000 and making about 17% of the nation's total income, paid almost 37% of the country's federal tax take. The top 5% - those above  $155,000 and earning almost 32% of the US' income, paid 59% of all taxes.  The bottom 95%, then, earned 68% of the country's income but paid only 41% of the federal tax take.

Conservatives say the middle class is the one not paying enough, when you look at these numbers, and that is undemocratic. The relatively few 1% are already paying for more than their share of taxes, and to increase them would drive money from Canada.

But the OWS groups say this is where the money to pull the US out of recession and to pay back people who lost their homes to unscupulous mortgage brokers and bankers, must come from.

And now they have pitched their tents and are refusing to leave until there is some movement on this issue.

From the Arab spring to the violent Toronto G20 protests to the Occupy encampments, we've seen a generation of young people rise up against what they see as an unjust distribution of wealth.  In all cases their political masters have sent in police against them, armed with rubber bullets and pepper spray.

One man, former Iraq veteran Scott Olsen, has sustained brain damage and cannot talk from what is said to have been a police "projectile."  Many others have been injured.

If anyone doubts the harm rubber bullets can do, they may recall that's what the police in Northern Ireland used during The Troubles.

These are the most serious and widespread protests since the 1960's brought us demonstrations over the U.S. being at war with Vietnam. 

On May 4 1970, then President Richard Nixon called in the National Guard at Kent State University during a protest against the US military invading Cambodia.

Four students were killed that day.

The Kent State shootings marked the turning point in public support for the US being at war with Vietnam, and Nixon himself.

The "Occupy" movement has many supporters across America and Canada, and yes, even in Toronto. Ontarians saw enough of violence by police and some protesters during the G20 riots.

Governments should re-read their history about Kent State before someone else is seriously injured or worse.

As the late Ontario PC cabinet minister 0Allan Grossman once said "We must give the poor their due - or they will take it from us."

You can find Susanna here: @susannakelley

Posted date : October 31, 2011
Taking It To The Street
Would Ontario have lost millions of jobs, and would Canadians have to worry about its government secretly spying on them without warrants, if we'd had a truly democratic system?
October 07, 2013
After two years of the gas plant scandal obsession, Susanna Kelley says the voters' real concern - high unemployment - may finally get the attention it deserves
October 02, 2013
Blame Ontario's conflict-ridden, antiquated political donation rules. It's time the system had a major overhaul, writes ONW's Susanna Kelley.
September 24, 2013
Premier Wynne's new transit panel shows a key difference between the two politicians, Howath tells Susanna Kelley. Actions, not endless talk, will differentiate them next election.
September 19, 2013
Firing those who aspire to your job on the eve of a convention where your leadership is shaky, to say the least, smacks of desperation, not strength, says ONW's Susanna Kelley.
September 16, 2013
Firing the Thornhill MPP for taking a housing allowance of nearly $21,000 for a Niagara On The Lake retirement home won't solve Tim Hudak's credibility gap.
September 09, 2013
And Now, A Dramatic Pause: With Kathleen Wynne and Andrea Horwath's pragmatism, the PC's in disarray, and Stephen Harper in pre-election mode, moderate politics is on the horizon for Ontario.
September 03, 2013
Stephen Harper and Rob Ford share the same damage control strategy, it seems: when in trouble, run away. This is leadership? More from ONW's Susanna Kelley.
May 21, 2013
Will all the political maneuvering leading up to Thursday's Ontario budget avert an election? ONW's Susanna Kelley says we may not know for weeks yet.
April 29, 2013
There's much more to the younger Trudeau's campaign than longing for the more optimistic days of Pierre Elliott Trudeau, says ONW's Susanna Kelley.
April 08, 2013
Kathleen Wynne's vision includes ideas from the PCs, NDP, former leadership rivals and others. Will her consensus politics keep her government afloat?
February 20, 2013
With the first solid evidence in that two women are the frontrunners in the Liberal leadership race, all politicos should note the achievement.
January 14, 2013