Advertisement NEWSROOM



  Ontario, Mike Duffy and Senate Reform


By Randall White

According to Phillip Blancher, a commentator from the eastern gateway to Ontario still known as the United Counties of Stormont, Dundas, and Glengarry, the Mike Duffy circus has come to town in Ottawa. 

And the “result of the trial, and the fallout from it, will become ‘Exhibit A’ for the cause of reforming the Senate.”

Andrew MacDougall, a former director of communications for Prime Minister Harper, has suggested something similar. 

How ironic it would be, Mr. MacDougall has urged, “if it was the trial of Senator Mike Duffy that became the catalyst to reform Canada’s least defensible public institution.”

The Canadian people would probably support something like this.

According to a recent Angus Reid Institute poll, about 45% of Canadians already want the archaic Canadian Senate — modeled on the 19th century British House of Lords — to be reformed.

Another 41% want to see it abolished, and only 14% think it should be left as is.  

The Supreme Court of Canada has made clear that nothing serious about Senate reform can be done without the involvement of provincial governments.  

Any kind of Senate elections would require the consent of seven provinces representing half the population.

Abolishing the Senate would require the consent of all the provinces — and the Senate itself!    

If the Duffy trial does finally become the catalyst to reform the notorious Red Chamber, it will most likely take the provincial premiers to get the ball seriously rolling.

There is a contrary view, however, which is that the premiers will never agree to serious Senate reform, because an effective, elected, and regionally representative Canadian Senate will only steal their thunder in federal-provincial relations. 

The logical provincial position on the future of Canada’s least defensible public institution is Senate abolition, not Senate reform. Quebec takes the position.

However, at least some of the smaller and/or less populous provinces will also vote against abolishing the Senate. Prince Edward Island is the one of those.

Since 2006, some will argue, the Harper federal government has slowly but surely stolen most of the provincial premiers’ thunder in federal-provincial relations.

The now rather long reign of Stephen Harper in Ottawa may be starting to change minds. 

What kind of view would Ontario bring to the table?  

On one part of this question I find myself disagreeing somewhat with Phillip Blancher from the eastern gateway to Ontario.

He writes: “The Senate of Canada must have equal representation of the provinces and territories. One jurisdiction cannot have an advantage or disadvantage over another when it comes to seats.” 

This is a lot like the E for "equal" provincial representation in the old Triple E Senate reform formula. And it has finally become clear to me that Ontario — with more than 38% of the current Canadian population, and living right next door to Canada’s French language heartland in Quebec — just cannot agree to the strict provincial equality part of the Triple E model.

No doubt, the Senate in the 21st century must be all about equal regional representation in some broader sense.

An obvious example is the four equal Senate regions (24 members each) of Atlantic Canada, Quebec, Ontario, and Western Canada, which prevailed from 1915 to the admission of Newfoundland as a fourth Atlantic province in 1949.

It may also be that equal regional representation in this sense today needs to grow at least a little closer to equal provincial representation.   

But then there is the problem that Quebec has never really been a province like the others. And since late 2006 the Canadian House of Commons has defined the Quebecois as a nation within a united Canada. 

Ontario has often been sensitive to the unique aspirations of its ancient Canadian sister province east of the Ottawa River since the first premiers conference at Quebec City in October 1887. 

It may still be too early to discuss the effect of Mike Duffy trial on all this.

But Premier Wynne herself has expressed interest in talking with her fellow premiers about Senate reform. Her aides at Queen's Park will undoubtedly be keeping an eye on any potential reform of this, one of Canada's oldest institutions.  

About Randall White

Randall White is a former senior policy advisor with the Ontario Ministry of Finance, and a former economist with the Ontario Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. He is the author of Ontario 1610-1985: A Political and Economic History and Ontario Since 1985. He writes frequently about Ontario politics.
Posted date : April 14, 2015

View all of Randall White's columns NEWSROOM
The Liberals won three of four by-elections this week, including a seat in an area they haven't taken since 1949. What do the results mean? Mahoney, Stewart and Parkin debate.
December 12, 2017
Is the centre-left getting crowded? The PC's, Liberals and NDP all seem to be targeting voters there. Which will win them?
December 11, 2017
Canada is redoubling diplomatic efforts to avoid the threat of nuclear weapons hitting Canada and the U.S. Mahoney, Stewart and Parkin on what can be done.
December 05, 2017
What happens when water pollution becomes "nobody's problem?" Ontario has it's own sorry history of water poisoning, and its ecological sins now reach international waters.
December 03, 2017
Postmedia and Torstar are cutting nearly 300 jobs and closing more than 30 newspapers - most in Ontario. Can the government step in? Mahoney, Stewart and Parkin debate.
November 29, 2017
Immigrants in Ontario are much less likely to live in small towns than in big cities. That may make for targeted election policies in 2018.
November 26, 2017
There's plenty of it going on in Canadian politics, not just the U.S. We asked Mahoney, Stewart and Parkin how politicians need to conduct themselves - and avoid ending their careers.
November 22, 2017
Funding needs to be higher and long term to mitigate damages from climate change. It shouldn't just be about getting the Liberals re-elected.
November 19, 2017
The renegotiation of NAFTA resumes this week in Mexico City. What does Canada have to do to save NAFTA - or should it bother? Mahoney, Stewart and Parkin weigh in.
November 14, 2017
A recent series of lectures in Toronto might help Prime Minister Trudeau's search for an path towards reconciliation with Canada's First Nations.
November 12, 2017
Justin Trudeau's fundraiser and former Liberal PMs Jean Chretien and Paul Martin are linked to companies with holdings in offshore tax havens. Mahoney, Stewart and Parkin debate.
November 08, 2017
While populists in some countries say immigration and freer trade have caused inequality inside nations, globally it's a different story. More migration helps.
November 06, 2017